Monday, May 21, 2012

Woodland to Install Cameras on Buses

August 28, 2006 by  
Filed under General

There was an interesting article in the opinion section of the Daily Herald today. It was about Woodland School District 50 installing cameras on their buses. The Herald asks are “Cameras really needed on buses?”

          

Security and surveillance cameras have crept their way more prominently into the American landscape in recent years, showing up in more locations for more reasons than ever before.

The latest spot? School buses.

In a split vote, the Woodland Elementary District 50 board has decided to buy and install digital cameras and microphones on 93 buses.

The question that first comes to mind is, Why?

The official answer, of course, is to deter students from unruly behavior and, when problems occur, to identify those who created the disturbances so that they can be disciplined. Digital camera equipment gives drivers the ability to press a dashboard button to mark the spot on the recording where trouble occurs.

That’s a convenience for those occasions. But the question remains: Is school bus rowdiness so severe that it warrants spending $162,285 to lease the cameras and microphones for five years?

Board member Carla Little, who cast one of two dissenting votes, doesn’t think so. Besides saying that she’s philosophically opposed to placing cameras and microphones on buses, Little believes there have been too few discipline problems to justify the move.

Little’s skepticism seems well-placed. Indeed, up to this point, the Gurnee-based district has installed cameras only when problems have been reported. Which makes sense. Student disruptions undoubtedly are annoying to kids trying to mind their own business and can pose a safety hazard if they distract a driver.

Speaking more broadly, the use of cameras in public arenas generally can be justified under similar circumstances — when a camera’s presence might deter behavior that can result in serious harm. That’s the case with cameras mounted in vans in highway construction zones, where drivers who ignore speed limits too often cause deadly collisions. That’s the case, too, with cameras positioned to photograph license plates of motorists who create potentially lethal situations by driving around lowered railroad crossing gates.

But those are instances in which the hazards and resulting damage have been well-established. Whether misbehavior on a school bus falls into that same category is open to debate.

One board member, citing a cost to the district of less than $10,000 after a state contribution to cover the rest, said, “This is just one of those ‘let’s do it’ projects.”

Comments

One Response to “Woodland to Install Cameras on Buses”

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...
  1. [...] The article makes is seem like the board is doing a wonderful job making cuts. This makes you wonder even more about the decision to place cameras in their buses. What about those teacher raise given out in the last contract? These are the problems the board needs to held accountable for. They increased spending faster than revenue. They will be back at the taxpayer trough soon enough asking for more money. [...]