Stupid In America
- on 01.15.06
- General
- 6 Comments
- Digg
- Del.icio.us
I would like to talk about some of the highlights I saw in the John Stossel report Friday night. Here is a list of those things:
- Teaching playing monopoly in World Geography class
- Public Schools are give an A or B by 57% of the public
- Grandmother, ex-teacher taught her granddaughter to read and add in a week. The school she attended had failed to do that in months
- In international tests, American 4th graders above average and below average in high school. (Below Poland, Belgium, Chechoslovakia)
Follow the Money Segment
- Kansas City schools – got more money, some built Olympic size swimming pools, state of the art weight lifting. Test scores dropped, 2000 schools failed and lost accredidation even with the extra money
- Highlighted Education Myths : What Special-Interest Groups Want You to Believe About Our Schools and Why it Isn’t So
” target=”_blank”> by Jay Greene. Visit here to have Jay answer your questions.
- A private school in SC spends $3000 per student in comparison to State average of $9000 with better results
- An 18 year old SC student could only read at a fourth grade level. He was sent to Sylvan and had improved 2 grade levels in 72 hours. They also showed a meeting where the public school he attended thought he was making satisfactory progress.
- Ben Chavis is a former public school principal, runs an alternative charter school in Oakland, CA
- spends thousands of dollars less per student than the surrounding public schools
- “That is the biggest lie in America. They waste money”
- Students clean up school
- Students take care of lunch room
- Students run laps around block for gym
School Choice Segment
- One Good District has it’s own police. They invade people’s privacy by entering bedrooms to make sure kids live in the District.
- Florida ruling banning vouchers
- McKay Scholarships to help Special Needs students
- Belgium – attaches money to the kids so it goes to whatever school they choose to attend.
- SC State Superintendent (paraphrased) – Don’t suse SAT scores as an indicator
- SC Gov. – Tried to get vouchers approved, but was defeated by the Legislature 60-53. This came about when he was given an exception for his kids to attend a better school instead of the poor schools where he lived. He and his wife refused and put their children in private school.
Teacher Unions Segment
- Tolerate mediocrity, make it almost impossible to fire
- Process to fire a teacher in NY (See chart at Common Good)
- Washington Charter School – 95% go to college
- Milwaukee – Vouchers improved all schools, both public and private
- NY spends $20 Million per year for Rubber Rooms (Building where they put unsafe teachers so they are away from students. They get paid to do nothing because they can’t be fired.
I was very glad to see MSM finally reporting on this issue. I would like to salute John Stossel and ABC for telling the truth and speaking out. It is time for a national debate on school choice. Why should parents be forced to send their kids to bad schools? Good teachers will be rewarded with school choice. Students will learn more in all schools. True local control will be restored.












Nice recap of the show. I thought it was enlightening how willing the parents in CA were
willing to let the school officials just come into their home. The whole show demonstrated to
me how far we have fallen as a country.
Spunky
Just a few notes on comparing to Belgium -
Free schooling in Belgium is available from age 2 1/2.
After “elementary school” students either go on to college prep, vocational ed, technical ed,
or arts education. Data comparing US to Belgium is comparing apples and oranges.
The setup is the same in Poland. At “high school” students decide whether to go college prep (the
data that is being used for comparison) or vocational or technical.
This is not to say that the education system in the US is not in need of a serious overhaul – it
is. But these “comparisons” are really no kind of comparison at all.
[...] Why is the status being rescinded? My guess is that the teacher has appealed the decision which means it has to go to a hearing officer. I had spoken with a board member about a week ago on this situation. They told me they thought everything was taken care of and it was over. I guess they were mistaken. I keep hearing defenders of the school system talk about how you can fire a bad teacher. It’s not so simple is it? This teacher has now been under observation since April of last year. How much longer will it take to fire them if they are bad? How many kids are being affected by this teacher every day? Are you ok with a bad teacher teaching your child? There is another local school district with a similar problem teacher. They have decided it is easier to let them teach the rest of this year and then not bring them back next year. How fair is that to the kids that have to put up with a bad teacher for an entire year? Maybe we need a rubber room like New York. [...]
[...] On Real Clear Politics there is commentary by John Stossel. It is a segment from his latest show, Stupid in America. I want to highlight a few excerpts (Emphasis mine): [...]
I was delighted to see that John Stossel do a report on this matter. I worked in the school district that my son now attends and I saw a lot of bad teachers. I kept asking myself how in the world they were still teaching and now I know. I commend him for exposing what I have known for a long time, but no one seemed to believe me, because seventy-sum percent of parents believe their child’s school is doing a good job. Unless you are in there, you just don’t know what goes on. Thank you also for posting this and keeping the subject going!
Thanks for the insight. I plan to continue this until the Public Education system is fixed.